Claimant to Defendant Ratio
Claimant 75%
Defendant 25%

MBBCh, BA (Hons), MA (Oxon), MRCP, FFICM
Respiratory Medicine
Subspecialist interest in Severe Asthma and Complex Respiratory Disease
Intensive Care Medicine
Dr Andrew Chadwick is a Consultant in Respiratory and Intensive Care Medicine at the John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, where he leads the Severe Asthma Service and is Clinical Governance Lead for the Critical Care Unit. Clinically, he manages over 700 complex asthma patients each year. In addition, he is a full-time consultant at one of the UK’s leading academic Intensive Care Units (ITU), where he manages a wide range of critically ill patients, including those with major trauma, respiratory failure, sepsis, and other severe infections.
He has extensive experience in complex respiratory disease, peri-operative risk assessment, sepsis, and critical care, and has directed governance and audit programmes in one of the UK’s largest intensive care units. Dr Chadwick has also contributed to national and international research collaborations, with publications in leading journals including BMJ, Thorax, and the British Journal of Haematology.
As a medico-legal expert, Dr Chadwick provides CPR-compliant reports within 2–3 weeks, covering respiratory failure, severe asthma, peri-operative risk, and critical illness. His reports are clear, evidence-based, and structured, drawing on his dual expertise in respiratory medicine and intensive care.
Lead Consultant in Severe Asthma, John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford
Consultant in Intensive Care Medicine, John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford
Maternity and Newborn Safety Investigations (MNSI) -Â Subject Matter Advisor Respiratory Medicine
Dr Andrew Chadwick is a Consultant at one of the UK’s largest academic hospitals, a position he achieved following dual specialist training in both Respiratory and Intensive Care Medicine. He is a Fellow of the Faculty of Intensive Care Medicine, holds MRCP accreditation, and is GCP certified.
He maintains an active commitment to professional development through ongoing CPD with the British Thoracic Society, the Intensive Care Society, and the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine.
Claimant 75%
Defendant 25%
One Question, Answered from the Evidence
This illustration of method comes from outside the familiar territory of clinical negligence. In a criminal matter, a medical expert was asked a single, sharply defined question: whether an individual's breathing condition genuinely provided a medical reason for being unable to provide a breath sample of the kind required by a test.
The first thing the expert's approach demonstrates is the value of answering the precise question asked. It would have been easy to expand into a general commentary on the person's respiratory health. Instead the expert kept the opinion tightly focused on the specific issue: whether the level of impairment was consistent with an inability to exhale steadily for the few seconds the test required. Discipline about scope keeps expert evidence useful and keeps the expert within their proper role.
Second, the expert prioritised objective evidence over assertion, without dismissing the individual's account. The person reported a long-standing condition, and that account was taken seriously as a starting point. But the expert then examined the person directly and carried out spirometry, an objective, standardised measure of lung function. The move from what the person described to what could be measured is the heart of reliable assessment.
Third, the expert triangulated across independent sources. Alongside the examination and the objective testing, there was contemporaneous footage of the attempts to provide the sample. The expert reasoned from what a genuinely severe impairment would look like, visible distress, an inability to speak in full sentences, obvious signs of being unwell, and then asked whether the footage showed those signs. Comparing what the evidence would be expected to show against what it actually showed is a transparent and testable method.
Fourth, the expert was candid about incomplete information. Historical records were unavailable, having reportedly been lost. Rather than treat this as either fatal to the opinion or irrelevant, the expert stated plainly what was and was not available, and grounded the conclusion in the evidence that could be obtained directly. That transparency allows a court to see exactly how much weight the opinion can bear.
On the evidence, the expert concluded that the breathing condition was not of a severity that would have prevented the individual from providing a sample. The significance of the example, however, lies not in the conclusion but in the route to it. Had the objective testing and the footage pointed to genuine, severe impairment, the same method would have produced the opposite opinion with equal confidence. The method is neutral; it follows the evidence.
There is a broader point about the portability of good expert practice. Strip away the clinical chronology and the framework of a negligence claim, and what remains are the essentials: a defined question, objective evidence, triangulation across sources, and honesty about the limits of the material. These are exactly the habits that serve an expert in the most complex clinical case.
What travels to any instruction is this. Answer the question you were asked, not a broader one. Take an individual's account seriously, but test it against objective measurement. Reason from what a genuine impairment would look like, and check the evidence against that expectation. Draw on more than one independent source. And be transparent about what is missing, so that the weight of your opinion is plain to everyone who relies on it.